Skip to content

Balancing Act: AI, Automation, and Human Centric Work

IIA Roundtable Peer Insights

IIA clients leverage analytics maturity assessments, battle-tested frameworks, and cross-industry collaboration to prioritize and execute strategic enterprise data and analytics initiatives. We regularly check the pulse of trending topics for our community and facilitate critical conversations in virtual roundtable format for peer-to-peer exchange.     

In a recent IIA roundtable discussion, data and analytics leaders from diverse industries gathered to share their approach to balancing AI automation, augmentation, and human-centric work. The discussion covered a wide range of topics, from overcoming AI anxiety through education and engagement to AI use cases for productivity and efficiency gains. Here are the key takeaways:    

1. Cautious Integration of AI in Regulated Industries

Participants in the discussion expressed a cautious perspective on the adoption of generative AI (GenAI), acknowledging that it is at a hype cycle's peak. Many of the functionalities touted for GenAI can still be accomplished using traditional methods of analytics and automation, yet the future will likely see AI more deeply integrated as a supportive assistant across various industries. However, there's a consensus on the importance of careful evaluation and gradual adoption to ensure that AI applications are both effective and appropriate.

The conversation extended into practical applications of AI, particularly in sensitive areas like financial services, where the risk of technological errors could lead to severe consequences. For example, the concept of AI agents in customer-facing roles is under careful examination, with several companies preferring to watch the technology's evolution before full implementation. This conservative approach includes using structured decision-making tools like decision trees that categorize potential AI projects by risk levels to manage and mitigate potential impacts effectively.

The discussion also touched on how companies integrate AI into operations, with some sectors like manufacturing experiencing a rapid increase in AI interest, leading to the adoption of robust governance frameworks to oversee the use of technologies such as Robotic Process Automation and AI in big data architecture. Challenges remain in seamlessly integrating AI into customer service platforms, necessitating a strong architectural backbone to support the deployment of AI tools like virtual assistants across various communication platforms.

2. Navigating Challenges in Data Lineage and Governance

In the realm of data management, organizations face significant challenges in establishing effective data dictionaries, data lineage, and governance systems. The reliance on tribal knowledge, where only specific individuals hold crucial information, and the lack of intuitive systems hinder efficient operations. Sparse and inconsistent documentation compounds these difficulties, making it imperative for organizations to adopt more robust and accessible data management solutions. The introduction of third-party tools for data lineage scanning has begun to address these issues, though they still require substantial human intervention.

Many organizations can manage basic data lineage within specific systems, like Databricks or data warehouses, but struggle with tracing lineage from backend systems like ERP software. This limitation has prompted a shift in focus from trying to track lineage from source systems to enhancing lineage visibility within analytics platforms and outputs. The use of advanced tools that rely on query logs helps in mapping data interactions within the data warehouse, but challenges remain in achieving comprehensive lineage from source systems. As the technology evolves, there is optimism about the role of generative AI in standardizing metadata and improving the consistency and usability of data governance frameworks, aiming for a future where data management processes are more automated and integrated.

Research and Advisory Network (RAN)

How could you benefit from hundreds of C-suite level D&A executives at your fingertips? Get access to the leading network of independent analytics expertise, allowing you to apply real practitioner insights against initiatives, projects, and problems through RAN today.

3. Overcoming AI Anxiety with Education and Engagement

Across various organizations, participants have been actively addressing concerns surrounding the implementation of AI. Recognizing the common fear associated with new technologies, leaders encourage their teams to view AI as an evolutionary step rather than a disruptive threat. They highlight the continuity of technological advancements and advocate for embracing generative AI as a tool that enhances capabilities, allowing data engineers to execute tasks more efficiently through straightforward SQL and API interactions. The emphasis is on the potential of AI to expedite and improve processes, comparing its impact to the evolution from traditional to modern, high-speed vehicles, thereby maintaining essential human involvement while streamlining operations.

In response to AI apprehensions, organizations have implemented several strategic measures to demystify the technology. This includes providing controlled access to generative AI platforms, facilitating hands-on experience, and organizing educational sessions where employees can share their insights and successes with AI applications. These initiatives are part of a broader strategy that includes comprehensive training programs encompassing AI, analytics, and essential soft skills, which are crucial for navigating the complexities of AI integration. The aim is to foster a culture of learning and adaptation, preparing employees for future technological shifts and ensuring they possess both the technical and problem-solving skills required in an AI-enhanced workplace.

Human Resources departments often spearhead these training initiatives, drawing on a blend of internal and external educational resources to tailor content that meets specific organizational needs. Moreover, by establishing regular forums for discussion and exploration of AI use cases, organizations promote a participatory approach to technology adoption. This not only alleviates fears but also cultivates an environment where AI is seen as a valuable tool for achieving competitive advantage, rather than a replacement for human jobs. Through these efforts, AI is gradually being integrated into daily operations, enhancing productivity and fostering an innovative, forward-thinking workplace culture.

4. AI as an Enhancer of Productivity and Efficiency

Participants discussed their diverse experiences and strategies regarding AI integration within their organizations, highlighting various applications and challenges. They emphasized leveraging AI to enhance efficiency and decision-making, using tools like Power Automate and Power Suite to simplify tasks and boost engagement. Leaders shared insights on the cautious adoption of AI, especially in regulated industries, advocating for a balanced approach to implementing technology, which includes a structured decision-making process like the decision tree analysis to assess potential risks and benefits. Moreover, initiatives like citizen development and AI-driven operational tools have been employed to improve workflow and data handling, proving essential in sectors such as software development and customer service.

The conversation also explored the broader implications of AI in transforming workplace practices and enhancing employee skills. Organizations are focusing on not only introducing AI technologies but also on cultivating a comprehensive understanding of these tools among their workforce. This involves extensive training programs covering both technical skills in AI and analytics and essential soft skills, ensuring employees are well-prepared for future advancements. Educational initiatives, such as AI training sessions and open forums for discussing AI use cases, have been instrumental in reducing reservations about AI, thereby fostering an organizational culture that embraces technological evolution positively.

In summary, the integration of AI across various sectors is seen as a crucial development to drive efficiency, enhance data management, and support continuous learning and adaptation within organizations. Leaders advocate for a proactive yet cautious approach to AI adoption, focusing on strategic planning, skill enhancement, and leveraging AI to solve specific organizational challenges effectively.

IIA virtual roundtables are exclusive, invite-only discussions designed to promote peer-to-peer exchange on pressing challenges in the data and analytics community. Seats are limited and reserved for C-suite data and analytics leaders or equivalent at mid- to large-sized enterprises. Conversations are geared toward non-digital native companies. If you meet these criteria, contact us for more information.